I was kind of expecting this.
When I posted my story about how I out-SEO’d the local SEO firms, I was #2 for the search term “St. Louis online marketing” and #1 for both “St. Louis Internet marketing” and “St. Louis marketing” in the Google 10-Pack.
Then, just 2 days later, I was #6 for “St. Louis online marketing” and not even on the first page for the other two terms.
Why?
I don’t know.
Maybe Google changed their algorithm for the local search rankings.
Maybe a ticked off competitor reported my listing to Google because they didn’t like me using the keyword “Internet marketing” in front of my company name.
Or maybe there’s some other reason that triggered this fall from grace.
In any case, it was fun while it lasted.
And, more importantly, getting “slapped” by Google for whatever reason gave me a reminder of why I chose to focus on PPC instead of SEO in the first place.
Here’s the deal folks.
If your business and/or business’ online marketing efforts relies on free traffic, you don’t have a business. You have a mirage.
Why?
Well, what happens when the traffic stops? (And I say “when” not “if” because it’s gonna happen.)
It could happen because Google changes their algorithm.
It could happen because the competition gets better at SEO than you.
It could happen because you (or your SEO firm) get lazy once you get that coveted first page ranking which causes you to tumble in the rankings.
But whatever the reason, if all you’re doing is relying on free traffic, the effect is devastating. In fact, here’s a story of a local business who fell off the first page of Google and ended up going out of business.
If you know, however, that you can profitably pay for traffic to your website, it’s a whole ‘nother ballgame.
Because you know you can always buy more traffic. If traffic from one source dries up for whatever reason, you can buy it from somewhere else.
When you rely on “free” traffic, however, you just can’t turn the traffic faucet on that quickly.
One of the main reasons I was drawn to Google AdWords (pay per click advertising) in the first place is control.
You simply have more control over your advertising efforts when you pay for them. If you know you can pay $1 in advertising and get $1.01 or $2 or $10 in return, you are in control.
Then your business’ success is not determined by Google or anyone else. Because you can always buy more traffic. From Google. From Yahoo!. From MSN. From web sites. From blogs. Even from offline mediums.
When you know you can convert traffic into sales, you’ve got yourself a solid online marketing plan for your business and have firmly put yourself in control of your business’ success.
Listen, I know how appealing the thought of free traffic is. Especially for a small business. Especially in times like these.
But there are no guarantees with free traffic. You can spend months and months and pay an SEO specialist $1000s of dollars to try to get your business ranked #1 for your chosen keywords.
But you may never get there.
And even if you do get there, one little algorithm tweak by Google can send you spiraling back to oblivion.
To me, that’s an incredibly risky strategy.
Now my point here is not to say SEO isn’t important. It is, and will remain an essential part of any online marketing campaign.
But if it’s all you rely on and if you don’t first prove that you can profitably buy traffic and can turn that traffic faucet on at will, you’re putting your business in a very dangerous position.
Just one last point here. And it’s about diversity in marketing.
If I was relying solely on Google Local Search for traffic and leads for Words That Click, I’d be screwed about now. Luckily that’s not the case for me.
But some businesses do rely on one source to drive all their traffic. If that’s the case for you, my advice is to diversify. Quickly!
It’s critical that you have traffic coming from different sources – paid search, SEO, articles, videos, social media and more.
Yes, there will be one that you probably focus on more than the others and will probably drive more traffic than the others. But if it’s your only source of traffic (especially if it’s free) you’re in an extremely risky state.
So diversify your online (and offline) marketing efforts. Be wary of building an online marketing strategy that’s based on free traffic. And though I don’t plan to devote too much more time to it, I’ve still got a few more tricks up my sleeve so I expect to be back on top of the local 10-Pack soon!
{ 8 comments }














